303 Creative LLC v. Elenis

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 22 Feb 2022

  1. Artist Lorie Smith is a website designer who creates original, online content consistent with her faith. She plans to (1) design wedding websites promoting her understanding of marriage, and (2) post a statement explaining that she can only speak messages consistent with her faith. But the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act (CADA) requires her to create custom websites celebrating same-sex marriage and prohibits her statement--even though Colorado stipulates that she "work[s] with all people regardless of ... sexual orientation." App.53a, 184a. The Tenth Circuit applied strict scrutiny and astonishingly concluded that the government may, based on content and viewpoint, force Lorie to convey messages that violate her religious beliefs and restrict her from explaining her faith. The court also upheld CADA under Employment Division v. Smith, 494 U.S. 872 (1990), even though CADA creates a "gerrymander" where secular artists can decline to speak but religious artists cannot, meaning the government can compel its approved messages. The questions presented are:
  2. Whether applying a public-accommodation law to compel an artist to speak or stay silent, contrary to the artist's sincerely held religious beliefs, violates the Free Speech or Free Exercise Clauses of the First Amendment.
  3. Whether a public-accommodation law that authorizes secular but not religious exemptions is generally applicable under Smith, and if so, whether this Court should overrule Smith.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

Colorado’s public accommodations law barred discrimination by businesses open to the public, and Lorie Smith wanted to expand her website design business to create custom wedding websites while refusing to make websites celebrating same-sex marriages. The Court held that the First Amendment prevents Colorado from forcing her to create expressive designs that convey messages she disagrees with. Justice Gorsuch wrote that the websites were pure speech, that Smith’s work was expressive and customized, and that compelling her to speak would violate the rule against forced speech recognized in cases like Barnette, Hurley, and Dale. The Court said Colorado could not use its nondiscrimination law to conscript her voice, even though public accommodations laws serve important civil rights interests. It reversed the judgment below.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justice Kagan and Justice Jackson, dissented. She argued that the law regulates conduct, not speech, and that a public accommodations law may require a business open to the public to provide equal access without denying service to gay and lesbian couples. She said the Court was wrongly treating discrimination as protected expression and creating, for the first time, a constitutional right for a business open to the public to refuse service to a protected class. She warned that the decision confuses denial of service with protected speech and undermines the principle that neutral laws can require equal treatment.

Opinion written by Justice Gorsuch

Decided 30 Jun 2023 · Official report

600us1r58_7khn.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 5 Dec 2022

21-476_k43e.pdfOpen in a new tab