Questions presented
SCOTUS records
- Whether the district court issued an appealable interlocutory injunction when it invalidated Texas' duly enacted redistricting plan and ordered the parties to appear at a remedial hearing to redraw Texas House of Representatives districts unless the Governor called a special legislative session to redraw the Texas House map within three business days.
- Whether the Texas Legislature acted with an unlawful purpose when it enacted Texas House of Representatives districts originally imposed by the district court to remedy any potential constitutional and statutory defects in a prior legislative plan that was repealed without ever having taken effect.
- Whether any of the invalidated districts that were unchanged from the 2012 court-imposed remedial plan to the 2013 legislatively adopted plan (in Bell, Dallas, and Nueces Counties) are unlawful, where the district court in 2012 issued an opinion explaining why these districts were lawful.
- Whether the Texas Legislature had a strong basis in evidence to believe that consideration of race to maintain a Hispanic voter-registration majority was necessary in HD90 in Tarrant County, where one of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit told the Legislature it had to keep the district's population above 50% Spanish-surnamed voter registration to avoid diluting Hispanic voting strength.
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The case involved a challenge to Texas's redistricting plans, which were alleged to be racially discriminatory. The Supreme Court ruled in favor of the state of Texas, holding that only one out of several contested districts was drawn with an impermissible racial gerrymander. The majority opinion emphasized the need for plaintiffs challenging district maps on racial grounds to prove that race was the predominant factor in drawing those lines and not just one consideration among many. It also underscored deference to legislative intent unless there is clear evidence otherwise. This decision reversed earlier findings by a lower court that had invalidated multiple districts as being unconstitutional due to intentional discrimination against minority voters.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Sotomayor authored a dissenting opinion, joined by Justices Ginsburg, Breyer, and Kagan. She argued that the majority failed to properly consider evidence showing intentional discrimination against Hispanic and African American voters in Texas’s redistricting process. Sotomayor criticized the Court for disregarding factual findings from lower courts about discriminatory intent behind certain district boundaries and accused it of ignoring historical context demonstrating persistent efforts by Texas lawmakers to dilute minority voting power through gerrymandering tactics over decades. Her dissent highlighted concerns about undermining protections afforded under both Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act and constitutional guarantees meant to prevent racial discrimination in electoral processes.
Opinion written by Justice Alito
Decided 25 Jun 2018 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 24 Apr 2018