Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
Residents of Honolulu challenged Hawaii’s legislative apportionment as violating equal protection. The State Constitution gave the three smaller counties a majority in the senate, while Oahu, with most of the population, controlled the house through districts based on registered voters. The district court struck down the senate plan and later rejected a legislative interim plan because it used multi-member districts, then ordered a constitutional convention. Writing for the Court, Justice Brennan held that the district court should have allowed the legislature broader freedom to propose reapportionment and that the proposed interim senate plan, together with the existing house apportionment, had not been shown to fall short of federal standards. The Court said the Equal Protection Clause does not require single-member districts in at least one house, does not require total population from the federal census as the only standard, and allows Hawaii’s registered-voter basis for an interim plan so long as it produces a distribution not substantially different from one based on a permissible population measure. The Court vacated and remanded with directions to adopt the interim plan and retain jurisdiction.
Opinion written by Justice Brennan
Decided 25 Apr 1966 · Official report