The dispute was whether Hans Ackermann and his wife could get a denaturalization judgment set aside under amended Rule 60(b) after they chose not to appeal. The Court, in an opinion by Justice Minton, held that relief was properly denied. It said their motion was too late under Rule 60(b)(1), which allows relief for excusable neglect only within one year, and that their reasons did not amount to the kind of extraordinary circumstances covered by Rule 60(b)(6). The Court distinguished Klapprott v. United States because Ackermann had been free, had counsel, had a trial, and made a deliberate choice not to appeal, rather than being unable to defend himself.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Black dissented, joined by Justice Frankfurter and Justice Douglas. He argued that Rule 60(b)(6) should be read broadly to allow relief where fairness requires it, and that the District Court should have heard evidence on the motions. He said the petitioners were pressured to choose between appealing and losing their home, relied on advice from a United States custody officer, and later pointed to the reversal of their relative’s denaturalization. He criticized the Court for using narrow common-law concepts to defeat the Rule’s humane purpose.