Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
Justice Powell wrote for a unanimous Court. The case concerned TWA’s policy for captains who reached age 60 and could no longer serve as pilots. TWA let captains who were displaced for reasons other than age automatically “bump” less senior flight engineers, but captains retired because of age had to use bidding procedures and could be forced out if no vacancy was available. The Court held that this different treatment violated the ADEA because it denied older captains a privilege of employment on the basis of age. The Court also rejected TWA’s reliance on the ADEA’s defenses for a bona fide occupational qualification and a bona fide seniority system. But it reversed the award of liquidated damages, holding that TWA’s violation was not “willful” because the company did not know its conduct was unlawful and did not act in reckless disregard of the Act.
Opinion written by Justice Powell
Decided 8 Jan 1985 · Official report