Justice Black wrote that the cases concerned when taxpayers may deduct losses from embezzlement under the Internal Revenue Code and Treasury Regulations. The Court rejected the government’s rigid rule that the loss is always sustained in the year the money was stolen. It said whether a deductible loss has been sustained is a factual question that depends on the surrounding circumstances, including whether the amount and timing of the loss were known and whether recovery was possible. Because the district courts had found special facts in each case, the taxpayers were allowed to take deductions in the year the embezzlement losses were discovered and their amounts ascertained. The judgment against Alison was reversed, and the judgment for Stevenson-Chislett, Inc. was affirmed.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Mr. Justice Douglas and Mr. Justice Burton dissented, but the text provided does not include their reasons.