American Legion v. American Humanist Association

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 2 Nov 2018

  1. In the decision below, the Fourth Circuit held that a 93-year-old memorial to the fallen of World War I is an unconstitutional establishment of religion, merely because it is shaped like a cross. The Fourth Circuit reached this conclusion even though the memorial was designed to be a war memorial, has only ever been a war memorial, has only ever been regarded by the community as a war memorial, and is on public land only because of traffic safety concerns that arose 40 years after the memorial was built. The questions presented are:
  2. Whether a 93-year-old memorial to the fallen of World War I is unconstitutional merely because it is shaped like a cross.
  3. Whether the constitutionality of a passive display incorporating religious symbolism should be assessed under the tests articulated in Lemon v. Kurtzman, 403 U.S. 602 (1971), Van Orden v. Perry, 545 U.S. 677 (2005), Town of Greece v. Galloway, 134 S. Ct. 1811 (2014), or some other test.
  4. Whether, if the test from Lemon v. Kurtzman, 403 U.S. 602 (1971), applies, the expenditure of funds for routine upkeep and maintenance of a cross-shaped war memorial, without more, amounts to an excessive entanglement with religion in violation of the First Amendment.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The American Legion v. American Humanist Association case revolved around a 40-foot tall Latin cross, known as the Peace Cross, erected in Bladensburg, Maryland to honor soldiers who died during World War I. The American Humanist Association argued that the presence of this religious symbol on public land violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment which prohibits government endorsement of religion. However, in a 7-2 decision led by Justice Samuel Alito in June 2019, it was ruled that although crosses are inherently Christian symbols and thus have religious connotations; context matters and not all displays with religious content violate the Constitution's ban on establishment of religion. In this particular case, given its historical significance as a war memorial for over nine decades without any controversy until recently suggested it had become more secular than sacred over time and hence did not infringe upon constitutional rights.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

In the case of American Legion v. American Humanist Association, there was no formal dissenting opinion issued by any justice. The Supreme Court ruled 7-2 in favor of allowing a large cross to remain on public land as a war memorial, rejecting arguments that it violated the First Amendment's establishment clause. Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sonia Sotomayor were the two justices who dissented from this ruling but did not issue an official written dissenting opinion for this particular case.

Opinion written by Justice Alito

Decided 20 Jun 2019 · Official report

usrep101572.pdfOpen in a new tab