Ohn Bacon and Thomas Robins, Surviving Trustees of the Bank of the United States, William R. White and John Hooper, Citizens of Pennsylvania, Lewis Phoenix and John D. Beers, Citizens of New York, Stockholders of the Late Commercial Bank of Natchez, Who Sue on Behalf of Themselves and All Other Stockholders of Said Late Commercial Bank of Natchez, Who Are Citizens of Other States Than Mississippi, Who Shall Come in and Seek Relief by, and Contribute to the Expenses of This Suit, Complainants and Appellants, v. William Robertson, Philip Hoggatt, Henry Chotard, and John F. Gillespie, and Others, (Names Unknown,) Stockholders of the Late Commercial Bank of Natchez, and Citizens of the State of Mississippi
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
In this Supreme Court case, John Bacon and Thomas Robins, surviving trustees of the Bank of the United States, William R. White and John Hooper (citizens of Pennsylvania), Lewis Phoenix and John D. Beers (citizens of New York) sued on behalf of themselves as well as all other stockholders in the late Commercial Bank Of Natchez who were citizens from states other than Mississippi. The defendants included William Robertson, Philip Hoggatt, Henry Chotard and John F Gillespie - all stockholders in said bank who were citizens from Mississippi. The complainants sought relief by contributing to expenses for this suit against these defendants.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
In the dissenting opinion of John Bacon and Thomas Robins, surviving trustees of the Bank of the United States, William R. White and John Hooper, citizens of Pennsylvania, Lewis Phoenix and John D. Beers, citizens of New York v. William Robertson et al., it was argued that a state court could not exercise jurisdiction over non-resident stockholders in a suit brought by them against resident stockholders for an accounting under their trust agreement with respect to certain assets held by them as trustees on behalf of all parties involved. The dissent further argued that such matters should be decided in federal courts since they involve questions arising from interstate commerce which are beyond the scope or power granted to state courts under Article III Section 2 Clause 1of the U.S Constitution which grants original jurisdiction to federal courts over cases involving controversies between two or more states or between citizens from different states .