Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 30 Sep 2009
In Duren v. Missouri, this Court established a three-prong standard for determining whether a defendant was able to demonstrate a prima facie violation of the Sixth Amendment right to have a jury drawn from a fair cross section of the community. The circuits have split on the issue about the proper test for determining what constitutes a fair and reasonable representation of a distinct group from the community within the venires (jury pool) under the second prong of Duren. The Michigan Supreme Court ultimately concluded that the small disparities at issue here for African Americans (7.28% in the community as against 6% in the venires during the time period measured) did not give rise to a constitutional violation. The question presented is: Whether the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit erred in concluding that the Michigan Supreme Court failed to apply "clearly established" Supreme Court precedent under 28 U.S.C. § 2254 on the issue of the fair cross-section requirement under Duren where the Sixth Circuit adopted the comparative-disparity test (for evaluating the difference between the numbers of African Americans in the community as compared to the venires), which this Court has never applied and which four circuits have specifically rejected.
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
In the case of Mary Berghuis, Warden v. Diapolis Smith (2009), the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on whether a suspect's right to remain silent was violated during police interrogation. The defendant, Diapolis Smith, argued that his Fifth Amendment rights were infringed upon because he did not explicitly waive them before being questioned by police about a shooting incident. However, the court held in a 5-4 decision that unless and until the accused invoked his Miranda rights—rights intended to protect individuals from self-incrimination—he could be interrogated without an explicit waiver of those rights. This ruling clarified that silence alone after hearing one’s Miranda Rights does not invoke these protections; instead it must be expressly stated by the individual under questioning.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
In the dissenting opinion for Berghuis v. Smith, Justice Ginsburg argued that the jury selection process in this case was fundamentally flawed and violated Smith's Sixth Amendment rights to an impartial jury. She contended that Kent County’s method of drawing from sources which underrepresented African Americans resulted in a significant disparity between their proportion in the community and on juries. This, she believed, undermined public confidence in the justice system as it suggested racial bias or discrimination. Furthermore, she disagreed with majority's view about harmless error review application because it ignored systemic issues within Michigan's judicial system regarding minority representation on juries. Thus, according to her perspective, Smith should have been granted habeas relief due to these constitutional violations during his trial.
Opinion written by Justice Ginsburg
Decided 30 Mar 2010 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 20 Jan 2010