Questions presented
SCOTUS records
- The questions presented are:
- Did the court below err in holding that race cannot predominate even where it is the most important consideration in drawing a given district unless the use of race results in "actual conflict" with traditional districting criteria?
- Did the court below err by concluding that the admitted use of a one-size-fits-all 55% black voting age population floor to draw twelve separate House of Delegates districts does not amount to racial predominance and trigger strict scrutiny?
- Did the court below err in disregarding the admitted use of race in drawing district lines in favor of examining circumstantial evidence regarding the contours of the districts?
- Did the court below err in holding that racial goals must negate all other districting criteria in order for race to predominate?
- Did the court below err in concluding that the General Assembly's predominant use of race in drawing House District 75 was narrowly tailored to serve a compelling government interest?
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The case of Bethune-Hill v. Virginia Board of Elections in 2016 revolved around the issue of racial gerrymandering, a practice where electoral district boundaries are drawn to favor one race over another. The plaintiffs argued that twelve legislative districts in Virginia were racially gerrymandered, violating the Equal Protection Clause under the Fourteenth Amendment. They claimed that these districts were designed with an inflexible racial threshold which led to packing African-American voters into certain districts and diluting their voting power elsewhere. However, the District Court upheld all but one of those challenged districts as constitutional since race was not found to be a predominant factor in their creation. On appeal, the Supreme Court held that while it is permissible for states to consider race when redistricting if they have good reason to do so (such as compliance with federal Voting Rights Act), it cannot predominate over traditional redistricting principles unless strictly necessary under compelling state interest test.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
In the dissenting opinion for Bethune-Hill v. VA Board of Elections, Justice Alito argued that the majority misinterpreted previous rulings and incorrectly applied a standard of review. He contended that race can be one among many factors considered when drawing district lines without automatically triggering strict scrutiny under the Equal Protection Clause. The majority's decision to apply this level of scrutiny whenever race is a factor, he argued, was not supported by precedent and could lead to unnecessary litigation in future redistricting cases. Furthermore, he disagreed with their conclusion that District 75 was racially gerrymandered because it failed to consider compelling evidence showing other legitimate reasons for its design.
Opinion written by Justice Kennedy
Decided 1 Mar 2017 · Official report