Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 11 Dec 2015
North Dakota law makes it a criminal offense for a motorist who has been arrested for driving under the influence to refuse to submit to a chemical test of the person's blood, breath, or urine to detect the presence of alcohol. The Supreme Court of North Dakota held that the State may criminalize any refusal by a motorist to submit to such a test, even if a warrant has not been obtained. The question presented is: Whether, in the absence of a warrant, a State may make it a crime for a person to refuse to take a chemical test to detect the presence of alcohol in the person's blood.
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
In the 2015 case Birchfield v. North Dakota, the U.S Supreme Court ruled on three consolidated cases involving state laws that criminalized a driver's refusal to submit to a blood or breath test in suspected drunk driving incidents. The court held that while warrantless breath tests are permissible under the Fourth Amendment’s search incident to arrest doctrine, warrantless blood tests are not. Breath tests do not implicate significant privacy concerns beyond arrest itself and provide necessary information for law enforcement officers dealing with intoxicated drivers. Blood tests, however, involve piercing of skin and extraction of part of subject's body thus implicating more serious privacy interests which require obtaining a warrant unless there is an emergency situation preventing it.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
In the dissenting opinion for Birchfield v. North Dakota, Justice Sonia Sotomayor, joined by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg in part, argued that both breath and blood tests constitute a search under the Fourth Amendment. They contended that these searches should not be exempt from warrant requirements just because they serve a law enforcement need. The justices expressed concern over normalizing warrantless searches and eroding constitutional protections against unreasonable searches and seizures. They also disagreed with the majority's distinction between breath tests (which they found less intrusive) and blood tests (more intrusive), arguing this differentiation is inconsistent with privacy expectations protected by the Fourth Amendment.