The question was whether members of the armed forces could recover under the Federal Tort Claims Act for injuries or death that were not incident to their service. The Court, in an opinion by Mr. Justice Murphy, held that the Act’s broad language allowing any negligence claim against the United States included these claims, and that the statute’s exceptions did not bar them. The Court relied on the Act’s text, structure, and legislative history, which showed that Congress had not kept a servicemen exclusion in the final law. The Court also said this did not decide whether servicemen’s benefit payments should be deducted from tort damages, so it remanded for consideration of that issue.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Mr. Justice Frankfurter and Mr. Justice Douglas dissented, substantially for the reasons stated by Judge Dobie in the court below.