Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma and Shoshone-Paiute Tribes of the Duck Valley Reservation v. Michael O. Leavitt, Secretary of Health and Human Services, et al.

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 22 Mar 2004

  1. Whether the federal government can repudiate, without liability, express contractual commitments for which it has received valuable consideration, either by spending down discretionary agency appropriations otherwise available to pay its contracts, or simply by changing the law and the contracts retroactively.
  2. Whether government contract payment rights that are contingent on "the availability of appropriations" vest when an agency receives a lump-sum appropriation that is legally available to pay the contracts--as is the law of the Federal Circuit under Blackhawk Heating and Plumbing Co. v. U.S., 622 F.2d 539 (Ct.Cl. 1980)]--or is the government's liability calculated only at the end of the year after the agency has spent its appropriations on other activities, as the Tenth Circuit ruled below.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

In the 2004 case Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma and Shoshone-Paiute Tribes of the Duck Valley Reservation v. Michael O. Leavitt, Secretary of Health and Human Services, et al., the U.S Supreme Court ruled in favor of two Native American tribes who argued that they were owed money by the federal government for contract support costs related to managing programs previously administered by federal agencies under the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act (ISDA). The court held that these contracts are legally binding and enforceable by law, rejecting arguments from Health & Human Services that appropriations laws or other legal restrictions prevented them from fully funding contract support costs. This ruling affirmed tribal sovereignty rights over self-governance activities while also ensuring financial resources necessary for effective administration.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

In the dissenting opinion for Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma and Shoshone-Paiute Tribes of the Duck Valley Reservation v. Michael O. Leavitt, Secretary of Health and Human Services, et al., Justice Scalia argued that contract support costs should not be fully funded by Congress if they exceed available appropriations. He contended that while Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act (ISDA) contracts are legally binding, they do not guarantee full funding beyond allocated amounts in a given fiscal year. In his view, ISDA contracts only require payment "subject to the availability of appropriations," meaning agencies are only obligated to pay what has been appropriated by Congress even if this falls short of total contract costs. Therefore, he disagreed with the majority's interpretation that these contracts entitle tribes to full funding regardless of congressional appropriations.

Opinion written by Justice Breyer

Decided 1 Mar 2005 · Official report

usrep543631.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 9 Nov 2004