Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 14 Nov 2008
- Whether all as-applied challenges to the disclosure requirements (reporting and disclaimers) imposed on "electioneering communications" by the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002 ("BCRA") were resolved by McConnell’s statement that it was upholding the disclosure requirements against facial challenge “for the entire range of electioneering communications' set forth in the statute." Mem. Op. I, App. 15a (quoting McConnell v. FEC, 540 U.S. 93, 196 (200)).
- Whether BCRA's disclosure requirements impose an unconstitutional burden when applied to electioneering communications protected from prohibition by the appeal-to-vote test, FEC v. Wisconsin Right to Life, 127 S. Ct. 2652, 2667 (2007) ("WRTL II”), because such communications are protected "political speech," not regulable “campaign speech,” id. at 2659, in that they are not "unambiguously related to the campaign of a particular federal candidate," Buckley v. Valeo, 424 U.S. 1, 80 (1976), or because the disclosure requirements fail strict scrutiny when so applied.
- Whether WRTL II’s appeal-to-vote test requires a clear plea for action to vote for or against a candidate, so that a communication lacking such a clear plea for action is not subject to the electioneering communication prohibition. 2 U.S.C. § 441b. 4. Whether a broadcast feature-length documentary movie that is sold on DVD, shown in theaters, and accompanied by a compendium book is to be treated as the broadcast "ads" at issue in McConnell, 540 U.S. at 126, or whether the movie is not subject to regulation as an electioneering communication.
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
In the 2009 case of Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in a 5-4 decision that laws prohibiting corporations and unions from using their general treasury funds for independent "electioneering communications" violated the First Amendment's guarantee of freedom of speech. The court held that political spending is a form of protected speech under the First Amendment, and thus, government cannot suppress political speech based on the speaker's corporate identity. This landmark ruling effectively overturned two previous decisions: Austin v. Michigan Chamber of Commerce (1990) which upheld restrictions on corporate spending to support or oppose political candidates; and McConnell v. FEC (2003), which upheld part of Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act’s restriction on campaign expenditures by corporations and unions close to elections.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
The dissenting opinion in the Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission case, led by Justice John Paul Stevens, argued that the majority's decision was a radical departure from established precedent and would have serious implications for democracy. The dissenters believed that corporations should not be treated as individuals with First Amendment rights to free speech because they are not actual members of society. They also expressed concern about the potential influence of corporate spending on elections, arguing it could undermine political integrity and lead to corruption or even the appearance of corruption. Furthermore, they criticized the majority for deciding issues that were not necessary to resolve this particular case (a concept known as judicial restraint). Finally, they disagreed with how broadly the majority interpreted "corruption," stating their belief that undue influence over an officeholder’s judgment can occur without quid pro quo exchanges.
Opinion written by Justice Kennedy
Decided 21 Jan 2010 · Official report