Cox v. United States

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

Jehovah's Witnesses convicted for leaving or failing to return to civilian public service camp argued that their local draft boards wrongly denied them minister exemptions under the Selective Training and Service Act. The Court, in an opinion by Justice Reed, held that they could challenge the classifications in their criminal trials after exhausting administrative remedies, but review was very limited: a board's decision is final unless it has no basis in fact. The Court said the minister exemption regulation was valid, then concluded that the boards had an adequate factual basis to deny the exemption in these cases. It also held that the trial courts properly limited review to the evidence before the boards and that the issue was for the judge, not the jury. The convictions were affirmed.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Douglas, joined by Justice Black, dissented. He argued that Congress intended to exempt all regular or duly ordained ministers who preach and teach their faith and are recognized as ministers within their religious group, and that the petitioners fit that description. Justice Murphy, joined by Justice Rutledge, also dissented. He said the Court's very limited review standard gave too much deference to draft boards in criminal cases, where liberty was at stake, and that the evidence here was far too weak to support the convictions.

Opinion written by Justice Reed

Decided 24 Nov 1947 · Official report

usrep332442.pdfOpen in a new tab