David Siver Junior's Lessee v. Mary Lynn, William Lynn, George Lynn, John G. Lynn, James C.Lynn, Ellen Jane Lynne and others was a case heard by the Supreme Court of the United States in 1851 that dealt with property rights and inheritance laws in Maryland at the time. The dispute arose when David Silver claimed ownership of land based on an agreement he had made with his father-in-law prior to his death which granted him title to certain lands if he paid off all debts owed by his deceased wife’s estate within five years after her death. However, several other parties also laid claim to these same lands due to their relationship as heirs or creditors of the deceased woman’s estate who were entitled under Maryland law to receive payment from any proceeds generated from sale of said lands before they could be transferred into another party’s name. After much deliberation over legal precedence and interpretation of state statutes pertaining to such matters at hand ,the court ultimately ruled in favor of Silver granting him full title over said properties as per terms outlined in original agreement between himself and late father-in-law .

In the dissenting opinion of David Surniver Junior's Lessee v. Mary Lynn, William Lynn, George Lynn, John G. Lynn, James C.Lynn, Ellen Jane Lynn, Mary Magruder Jonathan W. Magruder and Anna B Tilghman Frederick Augustus Schley (who married Francina C.Lynn deceased), it was argued that the court should not have granted a writ of error in this case as there had been no substantial errors made by either party during trial proceedings or in their respective pleadings to warrant such an action being taken by the court. The dissent further argued that since neither party had raised any objections to evidence presented at trial or other matters related to procedure and practice before judgment was rendered then there could be no basis for granting a writ of error on appeal from said judgement as all parties were satisfied with how things transpired during trial proceedings leading up to final judgement being handed down by the lower court judge presiding over this matter .