Emulex Corp. v. Varjabedian

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 4 Jan 2019

Whether the Ninth Circuit correctly held, in express disagreement with five other courts of appeals, that Section 14(e) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 supports an inferred private right of action based on a negligent misstatement or omission made in connection with a tender offer.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

In the case of Emulex Corp. v. Varjabedian, the U.S Supreme Court was asked to determine whether a claim under Section 14(e) of the Securities Exchange Act requires proof of scienter or if negligence is sufficient for liability. The Ninth Circuit had ruled that mere negligence was enough, creating a split among federal appeals courts on this issue as other circuits required proof of intent (scienter). However, in April 2019, the Supreme Court dismissed its grant of certiorari as "improvidently granted". This meant they decided not to hear arguments and make a decision on this particular point after all. As such, no definitive ruling was made by the Supreme Court regarding whether claims under Section 14(e) require proof of scienter or if negligence suffices.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

The dissenting opinion in the case of Emulex Corp. v. Varjabedian argued that the Ninth Circuit Court had erred in its interpretation of Section 14(e) of the Securities Exchange Act, which prohibits fraudulent, deceptive or manipulative acts in connection with any tender offer. The dissenters believed that this section requires proof of scienter - a wrongful state of mind - rather than mere negligence as determined by the lower court. They contended that every other circuit to consider this issue has required proof of scienter and thus, it was inappropriate for the Supreme Court to decline review on such an important question affecting securities law and corporate transactions nationwide.

Opinion of the Court

Decided 23 Apr 2019 · Official report

usrep101572.pdfOpen in a new tab