Expressions Hair Design v. Schneiderman

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 29 Sep 2016

Ten states have enacted laws that allow merchants to charge higher prices to consumers who pay with a credit card instead of cash, but require the merchant to communicate that price difference as a cash "discount" and not as a credit-card "surcharge." The question presented is: Do these state no-surcharge laws unconstitutionally restrict speech conveying price information (as the Eleventh Circuit has held), or do they regulate economic conduct (as the Second and Fifth Circuits have held)?

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The case of Expressions Hair Design v. Schneiderman, 2016 revolved around a New York law that prohibited businesses from imposing surcharges on customers who chose to pay with credit cards but allowed discounts for those paying in cash. The plaintiffs, five businesses and their owners, argued that the law violated their First Amendment rights by controlling how they communicated their prices. They contended it was easier to impose surcharges than offer discounts due to psychological factors affecting consumer behavior. However, the Second Circuit Court ruled against them stating the law regulated conduct rather than speech because price is a matter of numbers not words. The U.S Supreme Court vacated this judgment and remanded the case back for reconsideration under First Amendment principles as it found that communication about prices (not just prices themselves) were affected by this statute; hence there was an element of free speech involved which required further scrutiny.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

In the dissenting opinion for Expressions Hair Design v. Schneiderman, Justice Breyer argued that the New York law in question did not regulate speech but rather regulated conduct. He contended that the statute merely prohibited businesses from imposing surcharges on customers who choose to pay with credit cards, which is a form of economic regulation and not a restriction on free speech. Therefore, he believed it should be analyzed under rational basis review - a more lenient standard of judicial scrutiny - instead of heightened scrutiny as applied by the majority opinion. Under this standard, he concluded that there was no First Amendment violation because states have legitimate interests in preventing consumer deception and maintaining an efficient marketplace.

Opinion written by Justice Roberts

Decided 29 Mar 2017 · Official report

usrep101572.pdfOpen in a new tab