Fay v. New York

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The case challenged New York’s special or blue ribbon jury system in counties with large populations. The defendants argued that it denied due process and equal protection because it narrowed the pool from which juries were drawn and excluded certain classes of people. The Court, in an opinion by Justice Jackson, held that the statute was not unconstitutional on its face and that the defendants had not proved purposeful discrimination or unfairness in the way the special jury was selected or used in their case. The Court said the state had latitude to adopt administrative jury procedures suited to crowded courts, that the selection standards were reasonably related to juror fitness, and that the record did not show a denial of a fair trial. It affirmed the convictions.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Murphy dissented. He argued that the Equal Protection Clause requires juries to be drawn impartially from a cross section of the community and without systematic and intentional exclusion of qualified groups. He said the blue ribbon jury system rested on such exclusion and used intelligence standards that in practice allowed officials to eliminate people from the panel in a way that destroyed its representative character. He concluded that the panel denied equal protection to defendants tried by it.

Opinion written by Justice Jackson

Decided 23 Jun 1947 · Official report

usrep332261.pdfOpen in a new tab