Federal Republic of Germany v. Philipp

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 2 Jul 2020

  1. Whether the "expropriation exception" of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, 28 U.S.C. § 1605(a)(3), which abrogates foreign sovereign immunity when "rights in property taken in violation of international law are in issue," provides jurisdiction over claims that a foreign sovereign has violated international human-rights law when taking property from its own national within its own borders, even though such claims do not implicate the established international law governing states' responsibility for takings of property.
  2. Whether the doctrine of international comity is unavailable in cases against foreign sovereigns, even in cases of considerable historical and political significance to the foreign sovereign, and even where the foreign nation has a domestic framework for addressing the claims.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

In the case Federal Republic of Germany v. Philipp, 2020, the U.S Supreme Court ruled in favor of Germany and Spain over claims to art seized by Nazi forces during World War II. The plaintiffs were descendants of German Jewish art dealers who alleged that their ancestors were forced to sell a collection known as Guelph Treasure under duress to Prussian Prime Minister Hermann Goering in 1935. They sought restitution for this property from Germany and an agency called Stiftung Preussischer Kulturbesitz (SPK). In another claim against Spain's Thyssen-Bornemisza Museum, Cassirer argued that his grandmother was compelled to surrender a Camille Pissarro painting before fleeing Nazi persecution. The court unanimously held that both cases fell within the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act’s expropriation exception which bars lawsuits against foreign countries except those involving rights in property taken in violation of international law. Justice Breyer wrote for the court stating "We need not decide whether the sale at issue here violated international law," but rather if it constituted genocidal taking - which they concluded it did not.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

In the dissenting opinion for Federal Republic of Germany v. Philipp, Justice Gorsuch, joined by Justice Thomas, argued that the majority's decision to dismiss the case based on international comity was incorrect and inconsistent with previous rulings. They contended that it is not within a court’s purview to decide whether or not a foreign nation has violated international law; rather this should be left up to political branches like Congress and executive agencies who have expertise in handling diplomatic relations. The justices also expressed concern over how this ruling could potentially limit U.S citizens' ability to seek justice against foreign governments in American courts for violations of human rights or property thefts committed abroad.

Opinion written by Justice Roberts

Decided 3 Feb 2021 · Official report

usrep101572.pdfOpen in a new tab