Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The case involved a dispute between Franklin Mint Corp. and Trans World Airlines, Inc. (TWA) regarding the liability limits for lost or damaged baggage under the Warsaw Convention, an international treaty governing air carrier liability. Franklin Mint had shipped rare coins with TWA that were subsequently lost during transit. The central issue was whether TWA's liability should be limited to $9.07 per pound as stipulated by the Warsaw Convention or if higher damages could be claimed due to alleged willful misconduct by TWA employees leading to the loss of goods. The Supreme Court held that unless there is clear evidence of willful misconduct directly causing damage, carriers are entitled to limit their liability according to established treaty provisions.
Opinion written by Justice O'Connor
Decided 17 Apr 1984 · Official report