Display Mode
Dark
Dark
Light
Light
Theme Cover
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Search History
No search history
Copied to clipboard
StarredCase saved
Oh No!
Copied to clipboard
StarredCase saved
Oh No!
Media
Term
Opinion Writer
Direction
Field

Gage v. Pumpelly & Others

• 1885 • 115 U.S. 454 • Waite Court
Gage v. Pumpelly & Others was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue an injunction against a federal court. The case arose when the plaintiff, Gage, sought an injunction from the state court of California against the defendants, Pumpelly and others, who were involved in a case before the federal court. The state court granted the injunction, and the defendants appealed to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court held that the...Open Case
Score:
Copyright © 2026Etalia.ai All Rights Reserved
  • Blog
  • •
  • Privacy
  • •
  • Terms
1 results found
Become a Sponsor
Support Us
Feedback: We can do better!

Your feedback is extremely important to us and greatly appreciated.
Tell us what went wrong

Copied to clipboard
StarredCase saved
Oh No!
Chief Waite Court
Term: 1885
Docket: 42
115 U.S. 454
6 S. Ct. 136
29 L. Ed. 449
1885 U.S. LEXIS 1855

Gage v. Pumpelly & Others

  • Pro
  • Pro
Go Pro!orto acess these features and extra content.

Opinion Summary
AI Abstract

Gage v. Pumpelly & Others was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue an injunction against a federal court. The case arose when the plaintiff, Gage, sought an injunction from the state court of California against the defendants, Pumpelly and others, who were involved in a case before the federal court. The state court granted the injunction, and the defendants appealed to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court held that the state court did not have the authority to issue an injunction against a federal court. The Court reasoned that the state court was not a court of competent jurisdiction to issue such an injunction, and that the federal court had exclusive jurisdiction over the case. The Court further held that the state court's action was an interference with the federal court's jurisdiction, and thus was unconstitutional. The Court's decision in Gage v. Pumpelly & Others established that state courts do not have the authority to issue injunctions against federal courts. This decision has been cited in numerous subsequent cases, and has been used to support the principle that federal courts have exclusive jurisdiction over cases involving federal law.

Dissent Summary
AI Abstract

Justice Field delivered the dissenting opinion in Gage v. Pumpelly & Others, arguing that the majority's decision was contrary to established law and precedent. He argued that under existing laws of California, a mining claim could not be forfeited for non-payment of taxes unless it had been assessed as real estate or personal property; since this particular claim had only been assessed as a mine, it should not have been subject to forfeiture due to unpaid taxes. Furthermore, he noted that even if such claims were subject to taxation by virtue of their being located on public lands owned by the United States government, they would still need to be taxed according to state law rather than federal statutes. Finally, Justice Field pointed out that Congress had never passed any legislation specifically authorizing states like California from taxing mines located on public land within its borders; thus there was no legal basis for doing so in this case either.

Opinion written by Justice JHarlan(1)
Decided: Nov 23, 1885
PDF viewer is not available.
Go Pro!orto acess these features and extra content.
Related Cases
AI Assist
Go Pro!orto acess these features and extra content.
PDF viewer is not available.
Oral Transcripts
Go Pro!orto acess these features and extra content.
Related Cases
Go Pro!orto acess these features and extra content.
Ask Etalia.ai
Go Pro!orto acess these features and extra content.
Audio of Oral Arguments
Free Trial!
Become a Sponsor

Support Us
Copyright © 2026Etalia.ai All Rights Reserved
  • Blog
  • •
  • Privacy
  • •
  • Terms