The case involved Jehovah's Witnesses who had been denied minister exemptions under the Selective Training and Service Act, classified as conscientious objectors, and ordered to report to civilian work camps. One petitioner refused to report at all, while the other reported to camp and later left without leave. The Court, in an opinion by Justice Rutledge, held that the first petitioner was not required to report to the camp in order to finish the administrative process and could defend against the criminal charge by attacking his classification. It also held that the second petitioner did not lose that defense by reporting to camp, because he remained a civilian and was not subject to military jurisdiction. The Court distinguished earlier cases because the regulations here made the physical examination occur at different stages and did not leave open the same possibility of later rejection. The Court reversed and remanded for further proceedings.