Green v. United States

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The case involved a federal bank robbery defendant who later challenged his sentence under Rule 35. He argued that the sentence was illegal because the trial judge did not personally invite him to speak before sentencing, as Rule 32(a) requires, and because the court imposed sentences on both an ordinary and an aggravated robbery count. Writing for the Court, Justice Frankfurter said Rule 32(a) requires that the defendant personally be given the chance to speak, not just counsel. But the record did not clearly show that the defendant was denied that opportunity, so he failed to prove the sentence was illegal. The Court also held that although the third count did not charge a separate offense, the judge plainly meant to impose the maximum sentence for aggravated bank robbery, so the formal error did not require reducing the sentence. The judgment was affirmed.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Black dissented, joined by the Chief Justice and Justices Douglas and Brennan. He argued that Rule 32(a) plainly required a personal invitation to the defendant to speak before sentencing, and that the record showed this did not happen. He rejected the majority’s inference that the judge may have addressed the defendant personally, saying the transcript indicated the question was directed to counsel. He also criticized the majority for creating a new burden of proof and for refusing to enforce the rule in this case while announcing that judges should do so in future cases. He would have remanded for resentencing after compliance with Rule 32(a).

Opinion written by Justice Frankfurter

Decided 27 Feb 1961 · Official report

usrep365301.pdfOpen in a new tab