In the 1896 case of Iasigi v. Van De Carr, the U.S. Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over property rights and jurisdictional issues between two parties from different states. The plaintiff, Iasigi, was a Massachusetts resident who owned shares in an Arizona mining company that were seized by New York authorities to pay off debts owed by the company's president. He sued Van de Carr, a New York sheriff involved in seizing his assets under state law provisions allowing such action against non-residents for debt recovery purposes. The Supreme Court ruled in favor of Iasigi on grounds that he had not been properly notified about the seizure proceedings as required under due process protections provided by Fourteenth Amendment to Constitution; thus making it unconstitutional for his property to be taken without proper notice and opportunity for him to defend himself before court. Furthermore, they held that while states have power to regulate procedures within their borders - including those related with debt collection - these must still comply with constitutional requirements regarding due process rights of individuals irrespective of their residence status or location at time when legal actions are initiated against them.

The dissenting opinion in the case of Iasigi v. Van De Carr, 1896, argued that the majority's decision was inconsistent with previous rulings and principles of international law. The dissent contended that a foreign consul should not be allowed to sue on behalf of his countrymen without express authorization from their government. It also disagreed with the majority's interpretation of an 1868 treaty between the United States and Turkey, arguing it did not grant Turkish consuls such broad powers as claimed by Iasigi. Furthermore, it questioned whether a consul could represent non-resident foreigners who had no direct connection to him or his office. Lastly, they expressed concern about potential abuses if consuls were given too much power over private property belonging to citizens of their home countries living abroad.