Jack Daniels Properties v. Vip Products LLC

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 21 Nov 2022

Respondent VIP Products LLC markets and sells dog toys that trade on the brand recognition of famous companies such as petitioner Jack Daniel's Properties, Inc. The district court found that VIP's use of Jack Daniel's trademarks to sell poop-themed dog toys was likely to confuse consumers, infringed Jack Daniel's marks, and tarnished Jack Daniel's reputation. The Ninth Circuit, however, held that VIP's First Amendment interest in using Jack Daniel's trademarks as its own marks on funny dog toys conferred special protection from infringement claims and rendered VIP's commercial dog toys "noncommercial" and thus exempt from dilution-by-tarnishment claims. The questions presented are: I. Whether humorous use of another's trademark as one's own on a commercial product is subject to the Lanham Act's traditional likelihood-of-confusion analysis, or instead receives heightened First Amendment protection from trademark-infringement claims. 2. Whether humorous use of another's mark as one's own on a commercial product is "noncommercial" under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(c)(3)(C), thus barring as a matter of law a claim of dilution by tarnishment under the Trademark Dilution Revision Act.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The dispute was over a dog toy that imitated a Jack Daniel’s whiskey bottle, with jokes changing the label to “Bad Spaniels” and similar phrases. Jack Daniel’s claimed the toy infringed and diluted its trademarks. The Court, in an opinion by Justice Kagan, held that when a defendant uses a mark as a source identifier for its own goods, the Rogers test does not apply, so the case must be analyzed under the ordinary trademark likelihood-of-confusion standard. The Court said the First Amendment does not require a special threshold test for trademark use of a mark as a trademark, though parody may matter in the ordinary infringement analysis. The Court also held that the Lanham Act’s noncommercial-use exclusion for dilution does not protect parody, criticism, or commentary when the mark is used as a designation of source for the defendant’s own goods. The judgment was vacated and remanded.

Opinion written by Justice Kagan

Decided 8 Jun 2023 · Official report

599us1r35_3f14.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 22 Mar 2023

22-148_d523.pdfOpen in a new tab