Johansen v. United States

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The dispute was whether civilian crew members on United States public vessels could sue the United States for damages under the Public Vessels Act when they were injured or killed in the course of duty, or whether their only remedy was compensation under the Federal Employees Compensation Act. Justice Reed wrote that the compensation system was exclusive. The Court reasoned that the Public Vessels Act had to be read within the larger federal scheme of remedies, that Congress had not shown an intent to give public-vessel seamen an additional damages remedy, and that the 1949 amendments to the compensation law did not change that result. The Court also said it would be unfair and inconsistent to give public-vessel seamen an election of remedies denied to similar civilian seamen and that specific legislation would be needed to create an exception.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Black dissented, joined by the Chief Justice, Justice Douglas, and Justice Minton. He argued that the Public Vessels Act’s plain language allowed these suits and that the Court should not override that language by reading other statutes into it. He said Congress had given these seamen maritime remedies and then, in 1949, refused to strip them away, instead preserving their maritime rights and remedies. In his view, the Court was taking away rights Congress had granted and had declined to withdraw.

Opinion written by Justice Reed

Decided 26 May 1952 · Official report

usrep343427.pdfOpen in a new tab