Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 30 Mar 2015
- Whether the Eighth Amendment requires that a capital-sentencing jury be affirmatively instructed that mitigating circumstances "need not be proven beyond a reasonable doubt," as the Kansas Supreme Court held here, or instead whether the Eighth Amendment is satisfied by instructions that, in context, make clear that each juror must individually assess and weigh any mitigating circumstances?
- Whether the Confrontation Clause, as interpreted in Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004), and Davis v. Washington, 547 U.S. 813 (2006), applies to the "selection" phase of capital sentencing proceedings, as the Kansas Supreme Court held here, i.e., after a defendant has been convicted of capital murder and proof of eligibility for the death penalty has been presented in the guilt phase subject to full confrontation, or does not apply to such purely sentencing evidence, as at least three Circuits have held?
- Whether the trial court's decision not to sever the sentencing phase of the co-defendant brothers' trial here-a decision that comports with the traditional approach preferring joinder in circumstances like this-violated an Eighth Amendment right to an "individualized sentencing" determination and was not harmless in any event?
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
Justice Scalia wrote that the Eighth Amendment does not require a capital sentencing jury instruction stating that mitigating circumstances need not be proved beyond a reasonable doubt. The Court said its prior cases do not support such a requirement, and the instructions here did not reasonably create that misunderstanding because they clearly required proof beyond a reasonable doubt only for aggravating circumstances and for the conclusion that aggravating circumstances outweighed mitigation. The Court also held that the Constitution did not require severance of the Carr brothers' joint sentencing proceedings. It said the relevant claim was really one of due process, not the Eighth Amendment, and that the jury was presumed to follow instructions to consider each defendant separately. The Court reversed the Kansas Supreme Court and remanded.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Sotomayor dissented. She argued that the Court should not have granted review because Kansas had not violated any federal constitutional right and had, if anything, given defendants more protection than the Constitution requires. She said state courts should be free to experiment with procedures that protect fair trials, and that the Court's intervention risked discouraging States from adopting additional safeguards. She would have dismissed the writs as improvidently granted.
Opinion written by Justice Scalia
Decided 20 Jan 2016 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 7 Oct 2015