Ky. Ret. Sys. v. Eeoc

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 25 Sep 2007

This Petition involves a public employee retirement plan that includes normal and disability retirement benefits. A member who is eligible for normal retirement benefits based on attained age plus a minimum service requirement, or based on service alone, is not eligible for disability retirement benefits. Because age may be a factor in determining eligibility for normal retirement, it is an indirect factor in determining eligibility for disability retirement. Moreover, the calculation of disability retirement benefits is based upon actual years of service plus the number of years remaining before the member reaches retirement age or eligibility based on years of service alone; age may thereby be an indirect factor in determining the amount of disability retirement benefits. The question presented in this Petition is accordingly: Whether any use of age as a factor in a retirement plan is “arbitrary” and thus renders the plan facially discriminatory in violation of the Age Discrimination in Employment Act?

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

In the case of Kentucky Retirement Systems v. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2007), the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of a retirement system that had been accused of age discrimination. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) claimed that Kentucky's retirement plan was discriminatory because it used an employee’s age as a factor to determine eligibility for disability retirement benefits, which were more generous than normal retirement benefits. However, the court held 5-4 that while Kentucky's system did use age as a factor, it was not intended or used to harm older workers but rather to maintain pension equity among all employees regardless if they retire normally or due to disability before reaching normal retirement age. Therefore, this practice did not violate the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA). This ruling clarified how courts should interpret and apply ADEA when considering whether state policies are discriminatory based on their impact on older workers.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

In the dissenting opinion for KY. RET. SYS. v. EEOC, Justice Breyer argued that Kentucky's retirement system was discriminatory and violated the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA). He disagreed with the majority's view that there was no discrimination because all employees were subject to the same rules regardless of age; instead, he believed that these rules had a disparate impact on older workers who decided to continue working past normal retirement age as they would receive lower pension benefits compared to younger workers who worked for an equivalent period of time or made similar contributions into their pensions. Furthermore, Justice Breyer contended that this case should not be dismissed at such an early stage without allowing further investigation into whether Kentucky could justify its policy under ADEA’s “reasonable factors other than age” defense.

Opinion written by Justice Breyer

Decided 19 Jun 2008 · Official report

usrep554135.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 9 Jan 2008