The petitioners were held in contempt in Louisiana state court for refusing to answer grand jury questions after being offered full immunity from state prosecution. They said the answers could incriminate them under federal income tax laws, and the record showed cooperation between state and federal authorities. The Court affirmed the convictions per curiam on the authority of Knapp v. Schweitzer. Justice Brennan noted his view that reconsidering Feldman v. United States was inappropriate in this case, but that nothing in the decision foreclosed reconsideration in a proper case.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Chief Justice Warren, joined by Justices Black and Douglas, argued that the record showed real collaboration between state and federal authorities, so the state proceeding was being used as an instrument of federal investigation. He said the federal privilege against self-incrimination should have been recognized because otherwise compelled testimony in state court could be used or lead to use in federal prosecution. Justice Douglas, joined by the Chief Justice and Justice Black, separately argued that because Feldman allowed use of compelled state testimony in federal prosecutions, the Fifth Amendment right had to be protected in the state proceeding itself or it would be lost forever.