Niagara Hudson Power Corp. v. Leventritt

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The dispute was whether the Securities and Exchange Commission could approve a utility reorganization plan as fair and equitable even though it gave no participation to stock option warrants. The warrants let holders buy common stock at a fixed price, but the Commission found no reasonable expectation that the stock would rise enough in the foreseeable future to make the warrants have investment value. Writing for the Court, Mr. Justice Burton held that the Commission could treat the warrants as having no recognizable present value and was not required as a matter of law to give them compensation just because they had some low market price or a perpetual feature. The Court said the Act makes the Commission’s informed judgment, based mainly on foreseeable earnings, the proper guide, and that a value of zero may be lawful if supported by the circumstances. The judgment of the Court of Appeals was reversed and the District Court’s enforcement order was affirmed.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Mr. Justice Frankfurter, joined by Mr. Justice Black, dissented. He would have sent the matter back to the Securities and Exchange Commission for another look, for the reasons stated in Judge Learned Hand’s opinion below.

Opinion written by Justice Burton

Decided 15 Jan 1951 · Official report

usrep340336.pdfOpen in a new tab