Questions presented
SCOTUS records
02-575 NIKE, INC. v. KASKY Ruling below: California Supreme Court, 45 P.3d 243. QUESTIONS PRESENTED I. When a corporation participates in a public debate - writing letters to newspaper editors and to educators and publishing communications addressed to the general public on issues of great political, social, and economic importance - may it be subjected to liability for factual inaccuracies on the theory that its statements are "commercial speech" because they might affect consumers' opinions about the business as a good corporate citizen and thereby affect their purchasing decisions? 2. Even assuming the California Supreme Court properly characterized such statements as "commercial speech," does the First Amendment, as applied to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment, permit subjecting speakers to the legal regime approved by that court in the decision below? CERT. GRANTED: 1/10/03
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
In the case of Nike, Inc. v. Marc Kasky in 2002, the U.S Supreme Court was asked to determine whether a corporation's public statements about its business operations could be considered commercial speech and thus subject to laws against false advertising or if they were protected by the First Amendment as free speech. The lawsuit originated when California resident Marc Kasky accused sportswear giant Nike of making misleading claims about their labor practices overseas - specifically that workers were not being exploited and worked in safe conditions. Nike argued these statements were part of an ongoing public dialogue on international labor practices and should be protected under free speech rights rather than treated as commercial advertising which is regulated for truthfulness by state law. However, before reaching a decision on this issue, the court dismissed the case due to lack of jurisdiction without resolving whether such corporate communications are indeed covered by First Amendment protections.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
The dissenting opinion in the case of NIKE, Inc. v. Marc Kasky argued that Nike's statements about its labor practices should be protected by the First Amendment as commercial speech. The justices believed that Nike was participating in a public debate about its business practices and therefore had a right to defend itself against criticism. They expressed concern that ruling against Nike could have chilling effects on corporate speech, discouraging companies from openly discussing issues related to their operations out of fear of litigation. Furthermore, they disagreed with the majority's view that because Nike's statements were made in the context of selling products, they constituted false advertising rather than protected speech.
Opinion of the Court
Decided 26 Jun 2003 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 23 Apr 2003