Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The case asked whether the Double Jeopardy Clause barred Arizona from seeking the death penalty again after the state supreme court ruled that one aggravating circumstance used at the first sentencing was unsupported by the evidence. Justice White wrote that it did not. The Court said that when a conviction is reversed, the slate is usually wiped clean, and that rule applies here because neither the trial judge nor the Arizona Supreme Court had decided that the prosecution failed to prove its case for death. The judge’s rejection of the pecuniary gain aggravating circumstance was not an acquittal of that circumstance, and the state supreme court did not find the evidence legally insufficient to justify a death sentence. So a second sentencing hearing was allowed, and the death sentences were affirmed.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Marshall dissented, joined by Justices Brennan and Blackmun. He argued that the Arizona Supreme Court’s ruling that the evidence was insufficient to support the only aggravating circumstance found by the sentencing judge should have been treated as an acquittal of the death penalty, just as a reversal for insufficient evidence is treated as an acquittal at trial. He said the majority created an arbitrary distinction between these defendants and those who receive life sentences, and that once the death sentence was reversed for lack of evidence, the Double Jeopardy Clause should have barred a second chance for the state to find another basis for death.
Opinion written by Justice White
Decided 5 May 1986 · Official report