Polar Tankers, Inc. v. City of Valdez, Alaska

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 12 Dec 2008

  1. Whether a municipal personal property tax that falls exclusively on large vessels using the municipality’s harbor violates the Tonnage Clause of the Constitution, art. I, § 10, cl. 3.
  2. Whether a municipal personal property tax that is apportioned to reach the value of property with an out-of-State domicile for periods when the property is on the high seas or otherwise outside the taxing jurisdiction of any State violates the Commerce and Due Process Clauses of the Constitution.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The U.S. Supreme Court case Polar Tankers, Inc. v. City of Valdez, Alaska (2008) revolved around a tax dispute between the city of Valdez and Polar Tankers, a shipping company that transported oil from the Port of Valdez to refineries in other states. The city had imposed a personal property tax on large vessels like those owned by Polar Tankers which were not used for local commerce but docked at its port occasionally throughout the year for loading purposes only. The court ruled 7-2 in favor of Polar Tankers stating that this taxation was unconstitutional under the Tonnage Clause as it essentially amounted to charging ships for "the privilege" of entering their harbor or using their ports - something prohibited by federal law unless approved by Congress.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

The dissenting opinion in the case of Polar Tankers, Inc. v. City of Valdez, Alaska argued that the tax imposed by the city was not discriminatory or inconsistent with established principles of fair apportionment. The justices contended that it was a legitimate property tax on vessels benefiting from local services and protections provided by Valdez, such as harbor maintenance and emergency response capabilities. They also pointed out that other businesses operating within city limits were subject to similar taxes based on their property value. Furthermore, they disagreed with the majority's interpretation of "tonnage" under Tonnage Clause jurisprudence; arguing instead for a narrower understanding which would exclude general property taxes like those levied by Valdez.

Opinion written by Justice Breyer

Decided 15 Jun 2009 · Official report

usrep557557.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 1 Apr 2009