Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 25 Apr 2022
In Skinner v. Switzer, 562 U.S. 521, 524-25 (2011), this Court held that state prisoners may pursue post-conviction claims for DNA testing of crime-scene evidence in a civil rights action under 42 U.S.C.§ 1983. The Court made clear that a prisoner bringing such a § 1983 claim may seek "to show that the governing state law denies him procedural due process" after he has unsuccessfully sought DNA testing under available state procedures. Id. at 525, 530. The question presented is whether the statute of limitations for a § 1983 claim seeking DNA testing of crime-scene evidence begins to run at the end of state-court litigation denying DNA testing, including any appeals (as the Eleventh Circuit has held), or whether it begins to run at the moment the state trial court denies DNA testing, despite any subsequent appeal (as the Fifth Circuit, joining the Seventh Circuit, held below).
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The dispute was over when the 2-year statute of limitations began for a federal § 1983 procedural due process challenge to Texas’s post-conviction DNA testing procedures. Rodney Reed argued that Texas’s chain-of-custody requirement was unconstitutional and that his claim did not accrue until the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals denied rehearing. Writing for the Court, Justice Kavanaugh held that the limitations period began only when the state litigation ended, including rehearing, because a procedural due process claim is not complete until the State has finished providing the challenged process. The Court also rejected Texas’s arguments on standing, sovereign immunity, and the Rooker-Feldman doctrine. It therefore reversed the Fifth Circuit and held Reed’s suit timely.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Thomas dissented, arguing that the federal district court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction because Reed’s suit was really an impermissible attempt to obtain federal review of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals’ judgment. He said Reed was not bringing a genuine original case against the district attorney, but was instead challenging the state court’s interpretation and application of state law, which belongs in appellate review, not a § 1983 action. Justice Alito, joined by Justice Gorsuch, also dissented. He argued that Reed’s claim accrued no later than the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals’ April 2017 decision, and that waiting until denial of rehearing was wrong. He noted that the claim may have accrued even earlier, and said the majority’s rule was inconsistent with the ordinary accrual principles for § 1983 claims.
Opinion written by Justice Kavanaugh
Decided 19 Apr 2023 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 11 Oct 2022