Rice et al. v. Board of Trade of the City of Chicago

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The dispute was whether the Commodity Exchange Act and federal regulations had displaced Illinois authority to regulate the Chicago Board of Trade’s rules on grain warehousing and delivery. Rice complained that the Board’s rules were unreasonable and that some rules affecting warehousing had been adopted without Illinois Commerce Commission approval. The Court, in an opinion by Mr. Justice Douglas announced by Mr. Justice Black, held that Congress had not occupied the field so completely as to bar state regulation of futures trading except where state rules actually conflict with federal law. The Court said the Act gives the federal government comprehensive control over futures trading and some oversight of deliverable warehouses, but it does not automatically preempt all state regulation. Because Illinois had not yet adopted the specific applicable rules, any claim that state law conflicted with federal law was premature. The judgment was reversed.

Opinion written by Justice Douglas

Decided 5 May 1947 · Official report

usrep331247.pdfOpen in a new tab