Questions presented
SCOTUS records
- 01-1118 scheidler v. National organization for women, inc. Ruling below: ca 7, 267 f.3d 687. Questions presented
- Whether the Seventh Circuit correctly held, in acknowledged conflict with the Ninth Circuit, that injunctive relief is available in a private civil action for treble damages brought under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO), 18 U.S.C. § 1964(c).
- Whether the Hobbs Act, which makes it a crime to obstruct, delay, or affect interstate commerce "by robbery or extortion" - and which defines "extortion" as "the obtaining of property from another, with [the owner's] consent," where such consent is "induced by the wrongful use of actual or threatened force, violence, or fear" (18 U.S.C. § 1951(b)(2) (emphasis added)) - criminalizes the activities of political protesters who engage in sit-ins and demonstrations that obstruct the public's access to a business's premises and interfere with the freedom of putative customers to obtain services offered there.
- Whether, in this civil RICO action based on the nationwide conduct of thousands of abortion protesters over a 15-year period, the jury's determination of liability and award of treble damages - and the procedures and instructions used by the trial court to channel the jury's decisionmaking - satisfied the exacting standards for the protection of First Amendment rights mandated by NAACP v. Claibome Hardware Co., 458 U.S. 886 (1982). 01-1119 OPERATION RESCUE v. NATIONAL ORGANIZATION FOR WOMEN, INC. Ruling below: CA 7, 267 F.3d 687. QUESTIONS PRESENTED
- Whether the Seventh Circuit erred in ruling, in conflict with the Ninth Circuit, that private civil litigants may obtain injunctive relief under the federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) statute?
- Whether the "obtaining of property" element of the federal extortion statute, which is a predicate offense for civil RICO, may be satisfied, as the Seventh Circuit held, merely by a showing of "interference with the rights" of another?
- Whether civil RICO liability may be imposed where the jury is instructed on "generic" state extortion law, instead of the pertinent elements of each state's extortion law, as a RICO predicate offense?
- Whether the Seventh Circuit erred by affirming civil liability based on guilt by association and in holding, in conflict with the Second Circuit, that the First Amendment does not require a finder of fact to identify the alleged acts of unlawful conduct, and their alleged perpetrators, before imposing civil liability upon defendants engaged in protected expressive activity? CERT. GRANTED: 4/22/02 Limited to questions 1 and 2 presented by the petitions. Consolidated for one hour oral argument.
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The dispute was whether antiabortion protesters who disrupted abortion clinics committed extortion under the Hobbs Act, which would also support civil RICO liability. Chief Justice Rehnquist wrote that they did not, because extortion under the Hobbs Act requires obtaining property from another, and the petitioners interfered with and disrupted the clinics but did not acquire the respondents' property. The Court said the line between extortion and coercion matters, and any broader reading should come from Congress. Because the Hobbs Act predicates failed, the other RICO predicates based on state extortion and the Travel Act also failed. The Court reversed the RICO judgment and vacated the injunction, and did not decide whether private plaintiffs may get injunctive relief under civil RICO.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Stevens dissented. He argued that the Hobbs Act has long been read broadly to cover intangible property rights, including the right to exercise exclusive control over the lawful use of business assets and to solicit customers. In his view, the petitioners obtained property by using violence or threats to make the clinics give up control of those rights. He said the majority's narrow reading was inconsistent with prior federal decisions and would improperly retreat from the statute's established scope.
Opinion written by Justice Rehnquist
Decided 26 Feb 2003 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 4 Dec 2002