Secretary of Agriculture v. United States et al.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The case challenged Interstate Commerce Commission tariff rules for shell eggs that let railroads avoid liability for damage up to set percentages, called tolerances. The Court held that the Commission’s order had to be set aside because its findings did not adequately show that these tolerances would not limit carrier liability in violation of § 20(11) of the Interstate Commerce Act. Justice Harlan wrote the opinion. The Court said the record did not explain why damage claims would actually include the exempt damage, did not address how destination inspections and commercial practices affected the claims, and did not distinguish enough between kinds of damage or between physical damage and the legal loss claimed. Because the Commission had not shown that the tolerances would not operate as an unlawful limitation, the order could not stand.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Minton, joined by Justices Reed and Burton, dissented. He argued that the Commission had power to approve a reasonable tolerance rule measuring damage not caused by the carrier, and that the regulation fairly accounted for the inherent nature of eggs and pre-shipment damage. He said the Commission had made the necessary findings after a long investigation and that the tolerances were an adequate commercial approximation of noncarrier damage. He would have upheld the regulation and affirmed the judgment.

Opinion written by Justice Harlan

Decided 9 Jan 1956 · Official report

usrep350162.pdfOpen in a new tab