Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
Police obtained written confessions from two of the three murder defendants after lengthy questioning while they were in custody. The defendants argued that the confessions were coerced and that using them, and letting the jury decide coercion together with guilt, violated due process. Justice Jackson wrote that the Fourteenth Amendment did not require a different result. The Court held that the defendants had a fair hearing on coercion, that the state courts could properly find the confessions voluntary on this record, and that delay in arraignment did not by itself make them inadmissible. The Court also held that if the jury rejected the confessions, it could still convict on other sufficient evidence, and that the third defendant was not denied due process because he could not cross-examine the confessors or because parts of the confessions implicated him. The judgments were affirmed.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Black, joined by Justice Douglas, dissented, saying the Court weakened protections against secret confinement, coercive questioning, and denial of confrontation. He argued that due process should not allow convictions based on confessions extracted by police pressure or permit states to deny cross-examination of witnesses. Justice Frankfurter also dissented, saying due process requires careful scrutiny of whether confessions are truly voluntary and that the Court should not let strong evidence of guilt distract from whether police coercion produced the confessions. Justice Douglas, joined by Justice Black, argued that constitutional violations should not be treated as harmless simply because there was enough other evidence to convict.
Opinion written by Justice Jackson
Decided 15 Jun 1953 · Official report