In the 1908 case of Toy Toy v. Hopkins, United States Marshal, Chinese immigrant Toy Toy challenged his deportation order on the grounds that he was a natural-born citizen of the United States and therefore could not be deported under existing immigration laws. The Supreme Court ruled against him, upholding his deportation order. The court found that despite being born in America to Chinese parents who were legal residents at the time of his birth, he had lost his citizenship by moving to China with them when they returned home permanently and living there for over twenty years before returning to America as an adult. This decision reflected prevailing attitudes towards immigrants from Asia during this period in American history.

The dissenting opinion in the case of Toy Toy v. Hopkins, United States Marshal, 1908 is not readily available from public legal databases or Supreme Court archives. Therefore, it's impossible to provide a summary for this specific request. It should be noted that accurate and reliable information about U.S Supreme Court cases can usually be found through resources such as the official website of the Supreme Court of the United States, legal research websites like Justia or Oyez, and academic law libraries.