Jenifer Troxel, et Vir v. Tommie Granville

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The U.S. Supreme Court case Troxel v. Granville, 1999, revolved around the issue of grandparents' visitation rights versus a parent's right to make decisions about their child's care without government interference. The petitioners were the paternal grandparents of two girls whose mother had limited their visitations after their son (the girls' father) committed suicide. They sought increased visitation rights under a Washington state law that allowed any person to petition for such rights at any time. The mother argued this infringed on her constitutional right as a parent to direct and control her children’s upbringing. The court ruled in favor of the respondent, Tommie Granville (mother), stating that "so long as a parent adequately cares for his or her children...there will normally be no reason for the State to inject itself into the private realm of family." It held that while grandparents may seek visitation rights, these cannot infringe upon competent parents’ decisions regarding who can see their children and when.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

In the case of Jenifer Troxel, et vir v. Tommie Granville, Justice Scalia dissented on the grounds that there was no constitutional right for parents to direct and control the upbringing of their children. He argued that while this principle may be deeply rooted in American culture and tradition, it is not explicitly or implicitly protected by the Constitution. Therefore, he believed that it should be up to individual states to determine how much power parents have over their children's lives rather than having a federal standard imposed by the Supreme Court. Furthermore, he expressed concern about judicial activism and warned against courts creating new rights not found in the Constitution.

Opinion written by Justice O'Connor

Decided 5 Jun 1900 · Official report

usrep530057.pdfOpen in a new tab