United States v. Dickinson

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The dispute was over compensation for land affected by a government dam on the Kanawha River. The United States did not condemn the land, but raised the water level in stages, permanently flooding part of the respondents’ land, causing erosion to other parts, and creating intermittent flooding above the new permanent water level. Justice Frankfurter wrote that the Tucker Act claims were not barred by the six-year limit because the taking was brought about by a continuing process and the owners were not required to sue before the situation had stabilized. The Court also held that compensation could include erosion damage caused by the flooding, that preventable erosion could be valued by the cost of protection, and that the government had to pay full value for land it took even though some was later reclaimed with War Department consent. The Court found no reason to disturb the lower courts’ findings on intermittent flooding and affirmed the judgments.

Opinion written by Justice Frankfurter

Decided 16 Jun 1947 · Official report

usrep331745.pdfOpen in a new tab