The United States sued to stop and recover treble damages for alleged violations of a price-fixing regulation. The District Court held that the respondent’s prices complied with the regulation and dismissed the case. The United States appealed, but while the appeal was pending the commodity was decontrolled, so the Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal as moot. The United States did not ask to have the District Court judgment vacated. When the government then pursued the treble-damages action, the lower courts treated the earlier judgment as res judicata. The Court affirmed, saying the first judgment remained unmodified and involved the same parties and issues. It held that the loss of appellate review because of mootness did not create an exception to res judicata, especially because the United States could have protected itself by moving to vacate the judgment below and remand for dismissal.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
MR. JUSTICE BLACK stated that res judicata should not be applied under the circumstances shown. The text gives no further reasoning.