United States v. N. Y. Rayon Importing Co., Inc. (#2) et al.
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The dispute was over customs-duty refunds that had been paid into the Treasury after the claimant corporations were dissolved, and whether the Court of Claims could add interest to the refund judgment. The Court held that it could not. Writing for the Court, Justice Murphy said § 177(a) of the Judicial Code preserves the United States’ immunity from interest unless Congress has expressly authorized it, either by a statute specifically providing for interest or by an express contract term. Here there was no such contract term and the refund statutes contained no provision for interest. The Court rejected the view that fairness, equity, or delay by government officials could create consent to interest. It also said the immunity applies even to claims arising from pre-existing judgments, and that the statute governing set-offs against judgment creditors did not apply.