The cases asked whether the Federal Tort Claims Act lets the United States be sued for contribution by a joint tort-feasor and, if so, whether it may be brought into the case as a third-party defendant. The Court, in an opinion by Mr. Justice Burton, held that it does. It read the Act’s language as broadly waiving immunity for any claim for money damages caused by government employees acting within the scope of their duties, with no exception for contribution claims. The Court also said the Act’s use of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure allows third-party practice, so there was no reason to bar impleader. The Court rejected the Government’s argument that the different jury-trial rule under the Act required a different result, saying any procedural problems could be handled by the district court. The judgment in No. 218 was affirmed, and the judgment in No. 204 was reversed and remanded.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Mr. Justice Black and Mr. Justice Douglas dissented, but the text provided does not include their reasoning.