Opinions by Justice Catron, page 2
156 opinions, terms 1838 to 1863, newest first. 101 to 156 on this page.
The United States v. Ephraim Briggs
50 U.S. 351 · Decided 8 May 1850 · Justice CatronIn The United States v. Ephraim Briggs, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a federal statute that prohibited the importation of slaves into any port or place within the jurisdiction of the United States appli…
Rene La Roche and Mary, His Wife, Inez R. Ellis, Stephen P. Ellis, and Thomas La Roche Ellis, Minor Heirs of Thomas G. Ellis, Deceased, by Their Guardian Ad Litem, Charles G. Dahlgren, Plaintiffs in Error, v. the Lessee of Richard Jones and Wife
50 U.S. 155 · Decided 23 Apr 1850 · Justice CatronThis Supreme Court case involves the heirs of Thomas G. Ellis, deceased, who are suing Richard Jones and his wife for possession of a tract of land in Washington County, Maryland.
Michaela Leonarda Almonester, the Wife Separated from Bed and Board of Joseph Xavier Delfau de Pontalba, Plaintiff in Error, v. Joseph Kenton
50 U.S. 1 · Decided 3 Apr 1850 · Justice CatronMichaela Leonarda Almonester, the wife separated from bed and board of Joseph Xavier Delfau de Pontalba, brought a case against Joseph Kenton to the United States Supreme Court.
Adam L. Mills, John H. Gay, Charles Mullikin, John O'Fallon, William C. Wiggins, Andrew Christy, Elizabeth Christy, Mary F. Christy, Melanie Christy, Which Melanie Is the Widow, and Which Said Elizabeth Christy and Mary F. Christy Are the Only Children and Heirs at Law of Samuel C. Christy, Deceased, -- Said Children Being Infants, and Appearing by Said Melanie, Their Next Friend, -- Emily Pratte, Widow of Bernard Pratte, Lewis Penguet and Therese, His Wife, Stephen F. Niedlet and Celeste, His Wife, Louis v. Bogy and Pelagie, His Wife, Joseph Blaine and Aimi, His Wife, Which Said Emily Pratte, Bernard Pratte, Therese Penguet, Celeste Niedlet, Pelagie Bogy, and Aimi Diane Blaine, Are Children and Only Heirs at Law of Bernard Pratte, Deceased, Plaintiffs in Error, v. the County of St. Clair and James Harrison
49 U.S. 569 · Decided 21 Feb 1850 · Justice CatronAdam L. Mills, John H. Gay, Charles Mullikin, John O'Fallon and William C. Wiggins were plaintiffs in error against the County of St Clair and James Harrison in a Supreme Court case from 1850.
Samuel Marsh, William E. Lee, and Edward C. Delavan, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Edward Brooks and Virginia C., His Wife, Formerly Virginia C. Reddick, Charles P. Billou and Frances E., His Wife, Formerly Frances E. Reddick, Walter J. Reddick and Dabney C. Reddick by Eliza M. Reddick, Their Guardian, Heirs at Law of Thomas F. Reddick, Deceased, Defendants in Error
49 U.S. 223 · Decided 12 Feb 1850 · Justice CatronIn the Supreme Court case of Samuel Marsh, William E. Lee, and Edward C. Delavan v. Edward Brooks and Virginia C., his wife (formerly Virginia C. Reddick), Charles P. Billou and Frances E., his wife (formerly Frances E.…
Amedee Menard'S Heirs, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Samuel Massey
49 U.S. 293 · Decided 7 Feb 1850 · Justice CatronIn Amedee Menard's Heirs, Plaintiffs in Error v. Samuel Massey, the Supreme Court of the United States heard a case regarding land disputes between two parties.
Francis Surgett, Appellant, v. Peter M. Lapice and Edward Whittlesey
49 U.S. 48 · Decided 11 Jan 1850 · Justice CatronIn Francis Surgett v. Peter M. Lapice and Edward Whittlesey, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties could be enforced when one party had not received full payme…
The State of Missouri, Complainant, v. the State of Iowa, Respondent
48 U.S. 660 · Decided 13 Mar 1849 · Justice CatronThe State of Missouri brought a case against the State of Iowa in front of the United States Supreme Court.
James Erwin, Plaintiff in Error, v. Alfred J. Lowry, Curator of Alexander Mcneill, Deceased
48 U.S. 172 · Decided 1 Feb 1849 · Justice CatronIn the case of James Erwin v. Alfred J. Lowry, Curator of Alexander McNeill, Deceased, Erwin brought a suit against Lowry for damages resulting from an alleged breach of contract between himself and McNeill prior to his…
Joshua Kennedy'S Executors et al., Plaintiffs in Error, v. Lessee of Jonathan Hunt, John Hagan et al., Defendants in Error
48 U.S. 586 · Decided 28 Dec 1848 · Justice CatronIn the case of Joshua Kennedy's Executors et al. v. Lessee of Jonathan Hunt, John Hagan et al., the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a lessee had an obligation to pay rent for land that he leased from a decease…
Robert Marshall, Appellant, v. Susan G. Beall, Defendant
47 U.S. 70 · Decided 7 Mar 1848 · Justice CatronIn Robert Marshall v. Susan G. Beall, the Supreme Court of the United States heard a case involving an alleged breach of contract between two parties in which one party was seeking damages for non-performance by the oth…
Lewis A. Collier, Plaintiff in Error, v. John Stanbrough
47 U.S. 14 · Decided 22 Dec 1847 · Justice CatronLewis A. Collier was the plaintiff in error in this case, which concerned a dispute over land ownership between him and John Stanbrough.
The United States, Plaintiffs in Error, v. the Bank of the United States
46 U.S. 382 · Decided 18 Jan 1847 · Justice CatronThe United States brought a case against the Bank of the United States, claiming that it had violated certain provisions of its charter.
The United States, Appellant, v. Joseph Lawton, Executor of Charles Lawton, Martha Pollard, Hannah Maria Kershaw Wife of James Kershaw, et al.
46 U.S. 10 · Decided 5 Jan 1847 · Justice CatronThe United States Supreme Court case of The United States v. Joseph Lawton, Executor of Charles Lawton, Martha Pollard, Hannah Maria Kershaw Wife of James Kershaw et al., involved a dispute over the ownership and title…
Aspden and Others Complainants, v. Nixon and Others, Defendants
45 U.S. 467 · Decided 4 Mar 1846 · Justice CatronIn Aspden and Others Complainants v. Nixon and Others, Defendants, the Supreme Court of the United States heard a case involving an 1841 contract between two parties in which one party agreed to pay $1,000 for certain l…
Marie Nicolle Les Bois, Plaintiff in Error, v. Samuel Bramell, Defendant
45 U.S. 449 · Decided 3 Mar 1846 · Justice CatronIn the case of Marie Nicolle Les Bois v. Samuel Bramell, the plaintiff argued that a contract between her and defendant was invalid due to lack of consideration.
Isabella L. Mackay, Executrix of James Mackay, Zeno Mackay, George Anthony Mackay, James Bennett Mackay, Reuben Coleman and Eliza Lucy, His Wife, William Coleman and Amelia Ann, His Wife, Louis Guyon and Mary Catherine, His Wife, David Bowles and Julia Jane, His Wife, and Isabella Louisa Mackay by Isabella L. Mackay Her Guardian, v. Patrick M. Dillon
45 U.S. 421 · Decided 3 Mar 1846 · Justice CatronIn Isabella L. Mackay, Executrix of James Mackay, Zeno Mackay, George Anthony Mackay, James Bennett MacKay et al v Patrick M. Dillon (1846), the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a deed executed by an individual…
Lucius W. Stockton and Daniel Moore, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Harriet Bishop
45 U.S. 155 · Decided 28 Jan 1846 · Justice CatronIn the case of Lucius W. Stockton and Daniel Moore v. Harriet Bishop, the Supreme Court was asked to determine whether a contract between two parties could be enforced when one party had not received any consideration f…
Noel Jourdan and Joseph Landry, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Thomas Barrett et al.
45 U.S. 169 · Decided 27 Jan 1846 · Justice CatronNoel Jourdan and Joseph Landry, plaintiffs in error, brought a case against Thomas Barrett et al. The dispute was over the ownership of certain land located in Louisiana.
Gerard C. Brandon, Plaintiff in Error, v. Ralph W. Loftus and Floyd Whitehead, Defendants
45 U.S. 127 · Decided 16 Dec 1845 · Justice CatronGerard C. Brandon brought a case against Ralph W. Loftus and Floyd Whitehead to the Supreme Court of the United States in 1846.
Bernard Permoli, Plaintiff in Error, v. Municipality No. 1 of the City of New Orleans, Defendant in Error
44 U.S. 589 · Decided 5 Mar 1845 · Justice CatronIn the case of Bernard Permoli v. Municipality No. 1 of the City of New Orleans, Permoli brought a suit against the municipality for damages caused by an alleged breach in contract.
The United States, Appellants, v. William Marvin
44 U.S. 620 · Decided 5 Mar 1845 · Justice CatronIn the United States Supreme Court case of The United States v. William Marvin, the appellant argued that a contract between himself and an Indian tribe was invalid due to its violation of federal law.
Llewellyn Price, Jun., for the Use of Daniel W. Gaulley, Plaintiff in Error, v. Martha A. Sessions
44 U.S. 624 · Decided 19 Feb 1845 · Justice CatronIn Llewellyn Price, Jr., for the use of Daniel W. Gaulley v. Martha A. Sessions, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a deed from an infant heir should be held valid and binding in court proceedings.
Lessee of Daniel W. Gantly et al., Plaintiff, v. William G. and George W. Ewing, Defendants
44 U.S. 707 · Decided 11 Feb 1845 · Justice CatronIn the case of Lessee of Daniel W. Gantly et al., Plaintiff, v. William G. and George W. Ewing, Defendants, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a deed from an individual who had no title to land could be enfor…
Joseph Chatres, Executor of Benjamin Chaires, Deceased, and Peter Miranda and Gad Humphreys, Appellants, v. the United States
44 U.S. 611 · Decided 4 Feb 1845 · Justice CatronJoseph Chaires, Executor of Benjamin Chaires, Deceased and Peter Miranda and Gad Humphreys appealed to the United States Supreme Court after they were denied compensation for a land claim in Florida.
James Barry, Plaintiff in Error, v. Hamilton R. Gamble
44 U.S. 32 · Decided 14 Jan 1845 · Justice CatronIn the case of James Barry v. Hamilton R. Gamble, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a state court had jurisdiction over a dispute between citizens of different states that occurred in an area within the boun…
John Mcdonogh, Plaintiff in Error, v. Laurent Millaudon and Others, Defendants
44 U.S. 693 · Decided 14 Jan 1845 · Justice CatronJohn McDonogh, plaintiff in error, brought a case against Laurent Millaudon and others.
Pierre Chouteau, Sen., Plaintiff in Error, v. William Eckhart
43 U.S. 344 · Decided 16 Mar 1844 · Justice CatronThis case was between Pierre Chouteau, Sen. and William Eckhart.
Lessee of John Pollard, William Pollard, John Fowler and Harriet His Wife, Henry P. Ensign and Phebe His Wife, George Huggins and Louisa His Wife, Joseph Case and Eliza His Wife, Plaintiff in Error, v. Joseph F. Files, Defendant
43 U.S. 591 · Decided 16 Mar 1844 · Justice CatronIn the case of Lessee of John Pollard, William Pollard, John Fowler and Harriet his wife, Henry P. Ensign and Phebe his wife, George Huggins and Louisa his wife, Joseph Case and Eliza his Wife v. Joseph F. Files (Lessee…
William Kinney and James J. Mechie, Executors and Trustees of Robert Porterfield, Deceased, v. Meriwether L. Clark, William P. Clark, George R. H. Clark, and Jefferson R. Clark, a Minor by the Aforesaid George R. H. Clark His Guardian, Heirs a
43 U.S. 76 · Decided 15 Mar 1844 · Justice CatronThis case involved the executors and trustees of Robert Porterfield, deceased, who were suing Meriwether L. Clark, William P. Clark, George R. H. Clark and Jefferson R. Clark (a minor with his guardian).
William M. Gwin v. James W. Breedlove
43 U.S. 29 · Decided 31 Jan 1844 · Justice CatronWilliam M. Gwin sued James W. Breedlove for trespass and damages to his property in the Supreme Court of Mississippi.
Andrew Duncan, Plaintiff in Error, v. Isaac Darst, Henry Darst, and Jacob Darst, Defendants
42 U.S. 301 · Decided 14 Mar 1843 · Justice CatronIn the case of Andrew Duncan v. Isaac Darst, Henry Darst, and Jacob Darst, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties could be enforced if it had been made without consideration.
James C. Bell and Robert Grant, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Matthias Bruen
42 U.S. 169 · Decided 7 Mar 1843 · Justice CatronIn the case of James C. Bell and Robert Grant v Matthias Bruen, the plaintiffs in error argued that a deed from Bruen to them was invalid because it had not been properly acknowledged before a justice of the peace as re…
John Buchannon and Others, Complainants, v. Edwin Upshaw, Respondent
42 U.S. 56 · Decided 2 Feb 1843 · Justice CatronJohn Buchannon and others brought a case against Edwin Upshaw in the Supreme Court.
The United States, Appellants, v. Domingo Acosta, Appellee
42 U.S. 24 · Decided 14 Jan 1843 · Justice CatronIn the United States Supreme Court case of The United States v. Domingo Acosta, the court was asked to decide whether a Spanish subject who had been living in Florida since before it became part of the United States cou…
Thomas Armstrong and Others, Plaintiffs in Error, v. the Treasurer of Athens County, Defendant in Error
41 U.S. 281 · Decided 12 Mar 1842 · Justice CatronThis Supreme Court case involved Thomas Armstrong and other plaintiffs, who were suing the Treasurer of Athens County.
Robert Milnor, John Thompson, David Petrikin, and Levi Woodbury, Secretary of the Treasury, Complainants and Appellants, v. George W. Metz, Appellee
41 U.S. 221 · Decided 2 Mar 1842 · Justice CatronThis Supreme Court case involved four complainants and appellants, Robert Milnor, John Thompson, David Petrikin and Levi Woodbury (Secretary of the Treasury), who were appealing a decision made by George W. Metz.
Smith Harpending, and Others, Appellants, v. the Minister, Elders, and Deacons of the Reformed Protestant Dutch Church of the City of New York, and Others, Appellees
41 U.S. 455 · Decided 25 Feb 1842 · Justice CatronIn Smith Harpending, and Others v. The Minister, Elders, and Deacons of the Reformed Protestant Dutch Church of the City of New York, appellants argued that they were entitled to a share in certain church property which…
The United States, Appellant, v. John Breward, Appellee
41 U.S. 143 · Decided 10 Feb 1842 · Justice CatronIn The United States, Appellant v. John Breward, Appellee the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a state court had jurisdiction over a case involving an alleged violation of federal law.
The United States, Appellants, v. John M. Hanson and Others, Appellees
41 U.S. 196 · Decided 10 Feb 1842 · Justice CatronThe United States Supreme Court case of The United States v. John M. Hanson and Others involved a dispute between the federal government and private citizens over land rights in the state of Mississippi.
The United States, Appellants, v. John W. Low et al., Appellees
41 U.S. 162 · Decided 10 Feb 1842 · Justice CatronIn the United States Supreme Court case of The United States v. John W. Low et al., the issue was whether or not a certain piece of land in Michigan, known as "The Half-Breed Tract," belonged to the federal government o…
The United States, Appellants, v. the Heirs of George J. F. Clarke, and the Heirs of George Atkinson, Appellee
41 U.S. 228 · Decided 10 Feb 1842 · Justice CatronIn The United States v. The Heirs of George J.F. Clarke and the Heirs of George Atkinson, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a patent issued by Congress for land in Missouri was valid or not.
The United States, Appellants, v. Joseph Delespine, Appellee
40 U.S. 319 · Decided 2 Mar 1841 · Justice CatronIn the United States Supreme Court case of The United States v. Joseph Delespine, the court was asked to decide whether a defendant could be convicted for an offense that had been committed prior to Congress passing a l…
The United States, Appellants, v. the Heirs of John Forbes, Appellees
40 U.S. 173 · Decided 16 Feb 1841 · Justice CatronIn The United States, Appellants v. The Heirs of John Forbes, Appellees, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a federal statute that allowed for the recovery of land grants made by Spain prior to 1802 applied i…
The United States, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Gordon D. Boyd, and Others, Defendants in Error
40 U.S. 187 · Decided 9 Feb 1841 · Justice CatronThe United States brought a case against Gordon D. Boyd and others for the alleged illegal sale of certain public lands in Arkansas.
Samuel L. Fowler, Plaintiff in Error, vs. Harris Brantly and Others, Defendants in Error
39 U.S. 318 · Decided 9 Mar 1840 · Justice CatronThis Supreme Court case involved Samuel L. Fowler, the plaintiff in error, and Harris Brantly and others, defendants in error.
The United States, Appellants, vs. Elizabeth Wiggins, Appellee
39 U.S. 334 · Decided 21 Feb 1840 · Justice CatronThe United States Supreme Court case of the United States vs. Elizabeth Wiggins was a dispute over whether or not an individual could be held liable for debts incurred by their spouse prior to marriage.
William A. Carr, Appellant, vs. Samuel H. Duval and Others, Appellees
39 U.S. 77 · Decided 17 Feb 1840 · Justice CatronWilliam A. Carr, appellant, brought a case against Samuel H. Duval and others, appellees in the Supreme Court of the United States.
Joseph Evans, Plaintiff in Error, vs. Sterling H. Gee, Defendant in Error
39 U.S. 1 · Decided 21 Jan 1840 · Justice CatronJoseph Evans and Sterling H. Gee were involved in a dispute that was brought before the United States Supreme Court in 1840.
Carey Bagnell and the Executors of Morgan Byrne, Plaintiffs in Error, vs. George W. Broderick, Defendant in Error
38 U.S. 436 · Decided 9 Mar 1839 · Justice CatronIn Carey Bagnell and the Executors of Morgan Byrne v. George W. Broderick, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a deed executed by an attorney in fact for another person could be considered valid without being…
Meriwether L. Clark, Executor, and William P. Clark, George R. H. Clark, and Jefferson Kennerly Clark, an Infant Under the Age of Twenty-One Years, by His Guardian Ad Litem and Next Friend, the Said George R. H. Clark, Heirs at Law of William
38 U.S. 195 · Decided 28 Feb 1839 · Justice CatronMeriwether L. Clark, Executor, and William P. Clark, George R. H. Clark, and Jefferson Kennerly Clark were heirs at law of William in a Supreme Court case from 1839.
Charles King, Appellant, vs. Josias Thompson and Others, Heirs at Law of George King, Deceased, Appellees
38 U.S. 128 · Decided 23 Feb 1839 · Justice CatronCharles King, the appellant in this case, was appealing a decision made by the Circuit Court of Washington County.
The Bank of the United States, Appellant, vs. Elizabeth Lee, Edmund J. Lee, and Richard Smith, Appellees
38 U.S. 107 · Decided 11 Feb 1839 · Justice CatronThe Bank of the United States appealed a decision by the Circuit Court for Virginia to Elizabeth Lee, Edmund J. Lee, and Richard Smith in this Supreme Court case.
James Galloway, Junior, Appellant v. Henry R. Finley and David Barr, Appellees
37 U.S. 264 · Decided 12 Mar 1838 · Justice CatronJames Galloway, Junior appealed a decision made by the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Columbia.
Joseph S. Clarke and Richard S. Briscoe, Appellants v. William G. W. White, Appellee
37 U.S. 178 · Decided 22 Feb 1838 · Justice CatronIn Joseph S. Clarke and Richard S. Briscoe, Appellants v. William G. W. White, Appellee, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties could be enforced if it had been…
The Bank of the United States Appellants v. James Daniel et al. Appellees
37 U.S. 32 · Decided 27 Jan 1838 · Justice CatronThe Bank of the United States Appellants v. James Daniel et al. Appellees was a case heard by the Supreme Court in 1838 that dealt with whether or not state courts had jurisdiction over suits brought against national ba…