Akron, Canton & Youngstown R. Co. et al. v. Frozen Food Express et al.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The dispute was whether fresh and frozen dressed poultry fell within the Interstate Commerce Act exemption for motor vehicles carrying agricultural commodities, so that Frozen Food Express could transport them without a certificate of convenience and necessity. The Commission said the poultry was not exempt and ordered the carrier to stop. Justice Douglas wrote for the Court and held that dressed poultry is still an agricultural commodity and not a manufactured product. The Court said the exemption was meant to preserve low-cost transportation for farmers, and that the statute covers incidental processing that leaves the commodity with a continuing substantial identity. Killing, dressing, and freezing a chicken make it marketable, but do not transform it into a manufactured article. The Court therefore affirmed the district court's setting aside of the Commission's order.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Burton dissented, joined by Justices Frankfurter, Minton, and Harlan. He would have upheld the Commission's interpretation based on its reasons and long administrative practice. He argued that dressed poultry, like dressed meats, was not entitled to the agricultural exemption and that the Commission's judgment was supported by evidence and should be given the usual weight owed to informed administrative action.

Opinion written by Justice Douglas

Decided 23 Apr 1956 · Official report

usrep351049.pdfOpen in a new tab