Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The case addressed whether Yakima County could impose an ad valorem tax on land owned by the Confederated Tribes and Bands of the Yakima Indian Nation that had been patented in fee under the General Allotment Act. The Supreme Court held that such lands were subject to state taxation once they were allotted and conveyed in fee simple, as Congress intended these lands to be fully alienable. This decision was based on precedents indicating that when Congress makes tribal lands freely alienable, it also subjects them to local property taxes unless explicitly stated otherwise. The ruling emphasized the importance of congressional intent regarding tribal sovereignty and taxation issues.
Opinion written by Justice Scalia
Decided 14 Jan 1992 · Official report