Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 3 Oct 2022
Does the National Labor Relations Act impliedly preempt a state tort claim against a union for intentionally destroying an employer's property in the course of a labor dispute?
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The case involved a labor union’s strike against a concrete company after a bargaining agreement expired. Glacier Northwest alleged that the union timed the work stoppage to leave wet concrete in delivery trucks, causing the concrete to harden and damage the company’s property, and sued for conversion and trespass to chattels. The Court, in an opinion by Justice Barrett, held that the NLRA did not preempt those tort claims because the union had not shown that the conduct was even arguably protected. The Court reasoned that the right to strike is not absolute and does not shield strikers who fail to take reasonable precautions to protect an employer’s property from foreseeable, imminent danger. Accepting Glacier’s allegations as true, the union knew the concrete was highly perishable, coordinated the strike while trucks were loaded, and allegedly acted in a way designed to bring about the harm. Because that conduct was not arguably protected by the NLRA, the state court erred in dismissing the suit.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Jackson dissented. She argued that the Court should have stood aside because the Board’s General Counsel had already filed a complaint, which meant the strike conduct was at least arguably protected and should be considered first by the Board under Garmon. In her view, the majority improperly decided a fact-bound labor question that Congress assigned to the Board, and its approach risks undermining uniform labor law and the right to strike. She said the state court should have paused the case rather than reaching the merits of whether the conduct was protected.
Opinion written by Justice Barrett
Decided 1 Jun 2023 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 10 Jan 2023