Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The Court held that Alabama likely violated Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act when it adopted a congressional map with only one majority-Black district after the 2020 census. Chief Justice Roberts wrote that the district court correctly applied the long-standing Gingles framework, and that the record supported the finding that Black voters could constitute a majority in a reasonably configured second district, that Black voters were politically cohesive, that white bloc voting usually defeated Black-preferred candidates, and that the totality of circumstances showed the map was not equally open to Black voters. The Court rejected Alabama's proposed race-neutral benchmark approach, its claim that Section 2 requires proportional representation, and its arguments that Section 2 does not reach single-member districts or is unconstitutional as applied here. The judgments were affirmed.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Thomas wrote a dissent, joined by Justice Gorsuch, with Justice Barrett joining as to Parts II and III and Justice Alito joining as to Parts II-A and II-B. He argued that Section 2 does not apply to congressional districting at all because it covers ballot-access rules, not a State's choice among districting plans. He also contended that the Court's Gingles framework is unworkable and lacks a coherent benchmark for deciding when vote dilution has occurred. Justice Alito wrote a separate dissent, joined by Justice Gorsuch, arguing that the Court should not require Alabama to redraw its districts to create roughly proportional Black electoral control and that the Court's approach improperly elevates race in redistricting.
Opinion written by Justice Roberts
Decided 8 Jun 2023 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 4 Oct 2022